By David deForrest, General Manager
If you are a selling your home through ByOwner and
a realtor approaches you with a customer, are you obligated to pay commission
even though you make known your refusal to sign or verbally agree to any
commission in the event it goes to contract?
This is an interesting and tricky question. You can be "dead right" and still
be in plenty of trouble if you are careless on this.
A broker in Florida can enforce collection of a commission through the courts if
he procures a buyer for your property. He/she does not need a written listing
agreement to prevail in such a case. A judge might well, assuming the broker
could demonstrate that you knew he/she was acting as a broker and permitted
him/her to show your property and negotiate with a buyer for the purchase, rule
that you had implicitly agreed to compensate him/her without a formal agreement.
As to what compensation he/she could be awarded, the court would seek testimony
on the prevailing rates in your area for brokerage and work from there.
I would guess that judges have grown tired of hearing how sellers knowingly
permitted brokers to perform services for them even though they had "verbally"
refused to grant them any compensation. Attorneys have an expression for cases
that turn on two witnesses offering directly conflicting testimony as to who
said what to whom. It involves the word "contest." Cases like that are often
decided based on the actions of the parties and how a reasonable person would
interpret them. It is usually presumed that folks don't perform work without
anticipation of gain.
So your set of facts provided is a bit odd. You indicate that the seller
"verbally" refused to agree to pay. Why then does the Seller permit the broker
to involve him/herself at all? I think the Seller would be on stronger ground by
having a written understanding with a broker prior to permitting him/her to show
the property or to participate in negotiations. For example, you could both sign
a simple letter or other document which would give the broker permission to show
the property to a specific prospect on the basis that he/she would look to the
buyer for any compensation. You would then be on pretty firm ground if you were
challenged later on.
Of course, in the real world having the buyer pay a commission would boil down
to the same thing as "you" paying the commission. That is, one must recognize
that if a cost is to be added to the price of the purchase, a rational buyer
would reduce his/her offer accordingly. On the other hand, assuming you "get
your price" I suppose it makes no difference to you. But, knowing the human soul
as I do, I suspect it would gall you nevertheless. If it did not you would have
surely listed the property with a broker in the first place. It is a matter of
established fact that properties listed with brokers sell at higher prices and
quicker than those sold by owners. If this were not true, there would be no
point in anyone paying for brokerage and brokers would vanish like the makers of
buggy-whips did when the auto replaced the horse. Yet we remain and a reasonable
assumption is that on the whole we provide value for the fees we receive or the
public would not agree to bear them.
But, as I said, the Seller in your example, determined as he/she might be to
refuse compensation to this "altruistic" broker would be best advised to have
the broker confirm, in writing, his/her supposed willingness to renounce any
compensation before you let him/her perform for you.
Unless otherwise stated square footage and lot dimensions appearing herein are
derived from county records and may or may not be accurate.
If square footage is material to a transaction a survey or other measurement is
recommended. This information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Current or
previous year’s taxes may not accurately forecast future property taxes.
Property taxes can increase from one year to the next for various reasons.
This page, and all contents, are Copyright © 2023 by Buy the Beach
800 West Avenue, Miami Beach, FL 33139 USA
Licensed Florida Real Estate Broker
Miami Beach Real Estate * Real Estate Miami Beach * Miami Beach Income Property
* Miami Beach Realtor * Realtor Miami Beach
Real Estate Miami Beach * Miami Beach Florida Property * Relocation Miami Beach
* Investment Miami Beach * Miami Beach Realtor